New electrification index shows Italy’s high electricity costs holding back progress despite strong policies and storage
We Mean Business Coalition
Italy’s high electricity costs compared to natural gas are holding back electrification despite strong policies and some of the most advanced electricity storage infrastructure among major economies, according to new global analysis.
The findings come as Italy reaches an agreement with the European Commission on measures to limit the impact of rising gas prices on electricity bills for households and businesses, amid growing concerns over energy affordability and industrial competitiveness.
The analysis finds that Italy has established strong electricity market policies, nationwide smart meter deployment and the highest storage capacity relative to electricity generation among the 16 countries assessed. But electricity costs around 2.6 times as much as gas for industry, while delays in permitting new clean electricity projects and inconsistent electric vehicle incentives are limiting progress.
The Electrification Competitiveness Index assesses how far electrification has progressed in different countries, looking at what is happening on the ground as well as whether the right conditions are in place for further progress. Enabling and deployment factors offer a rounded picture of how ready economies are for businesses to electrify operations.
Italy scores 75% for enabling conditions but just 44% for deployment, placing it in the Index’s ‘potential for take-off’ group alongside Germany, India, Poland and the UK. Its strong policies supporting electricity markets, storage and industrial investment provide a foundation for faster electrification, but high electricity costs relative to gas, permitting delays and uneven uptake of electric technologies remain significant barriers.
Electrification, combined with clean power, can reduce economies’ reliance on fossil fuels, strengthen energy security, reduce exposure to volatile fuel prices, support growth and productivity, cut emissions and improve health through cleaner air. It will be a key focus at COP31.
Molly Walton, Director of Energy, We Mean Business Coalition said: “Italy has some important advantages for electrification, from its advanced electricity storage systems and smart meters to policies that help businesses secure long-term clean electricity supplies. But for industrial companies weighing up a switch from gas to electricity, the economics remain a major obstacle. Electricity that costs more than twice as much as gas makes it harder to justify investment in electric technologies.
“Italy’s efforts to tackle energy costs are an important part of the picture. Bringing down the price of electricity relative to gas, accelerating permits for new clean electricity generation and providing more consistent incentives for electric vehicles would help businesses make use of the infrastructure and policies already in place. That would strengthen industrial competitiveness and reduce exposure to imported fossil fuels.”
Key Italy findings include:
- Italy scores 75% for enabling conditions but 44% for deployment, placing it in the Index’s ‘potential for take-off’ group. Strong electricity market and infrastructure policies provide a foundation for electrification, but deployment has yet to match those conditions.
- Grids and power markets score 27 out of 30 for enabling conditions but 11 out of 30 for deployment. Italy has the highest electricity storage capacity relative to generation among the countries assessed, together with advanced grid digitalisation and smart meter deployment. High electricity costs and delays in permitting clean electricity projects remain barriers.
- Industry scores 16 out of 20 for enabling conditions and 10 out of 20 for deployment. Italy has established programmes supporting industrial efficiency and investment, but electricity costs around 2.6 times as much as gas for industry, weakening the business case for electrifying industrial processes.
- Road transport scores 9 out of 20 for deployment and 15 out of 20 for enabling conditions. Electric vehicle incentives and charging infrastructure support provide a foundation for growth, but uptake remains relatively low across most vehicle types, while uncertainty over the continuation of purchase incentives risks slowing further progress.
- Buildings score 11 out of 20 for deployment and 12 out of 20 for enabling conditions. Italy has achieved universal smart meter deployment, but electricity costs substantially more than gas for heating, while uptake of electric cooking remains particularly low.
- The Index identifies priorities including reducing electricity taxes and levies relative to gas, accelerating permits for clean electricity generation, maintaining consistent electric vehicle incentives, strengthening building efficiency standards and expanding support for industrial electrification.
The Index, developed by We Mean Business Coalition with support from RMI, assesses Australia, Brazil, China, Ethiopia, France, Germany, India, Indonesia, Italy, the Philippines, Poland, South Africa, South Korea, Spain, UK and US.
China leads the Index on electrification deployment, while the US risks losing momentum amid federal policy reversals and grid bottlenecks. France and Spain combine strong policies with progress on the ground, while other major European economies, including the UK, Germany and Poland, have yet to translate their policy frameworks into comparable results.
María Mendiluce, CEO, We Mean Business Coalition said: “Electrification is becoming a test of economic competitiveness and energy security. Those countries like China, France and Spain with strong deployment and enablers show what can happen when investment, infrastructure, industrial strategy and demand move together. Elsewhere, governments have put many of the right policies in place, but businesses still need affordable clean electricity, grid connections and the confidence to invest. The competitive advantage now comes from turning policy into delivery.”
The research finds a sizeable global implementation gap: the median Enablers score across the 16 countries is 67%, compared with 45% for Deployment, with 14 of the 16 scoring higher on Enablers than Deployment.
The gap between deployment and enablers reflects different challenges across countries, including the recency of some policies – many from this year in fossil fuel-importing countries, policy uncertainty, physical constraints such as grid connection delays, and incentives that are misaligned between fossil fuels and clean electricity.
The findings are released after the COP31 Presidency’s recent call for electricity to supply 35% of global final energy demand by 2035, up from just over 20% today. They also follow the first six months of the Hormuz crisis, when fossil-fuel importing countries paid an extra $330 billion for seaborne oil and LNG. According to the IEA, faster electrification could cut fossil import costs by around $400 billion a year by 2035.
The Index identifies a range of actions governments can take, depending on their national circumstances, including making electricity more affordable relative to fossil fuels, investing in modern grids, speeding up connections and permitting, reforming electricity markets, and providing clear, consistent policies, financial incentives and regulatory standards that encourage businesses to invest in electric technologies.
The analysis assesses 52 indicators covering grids and power markets, road transport, industry, buildings and cross-cutting readiness. It measures Deployment and Enablers separately to show not simply how electrified countries are today, but whether they are creating the conditions for further investment.
-ends
For more information, briefings and interviews [email protected] +44 7432533080
- The Index was developed with RMI and is part of We Mean Business Coalition’s Electric Advantage programme.
- Separate WMBC polling, done in partnership with E3G and GRA, of 1,994 senior business leaders across 18 countries found 90% expect their operations to be largely electrified by 2035 and 91% believe electrification will strengthen energy security. It also found that 63% say their country’s power system is not keeping pace with their electrification needs, while half report delaying or cancelling electrification projects because of barriers including grid infrastructure.
- WMBC is a founding partner of the campaign, which is working to accelerate clean electrification internationally. campaign, which is working to accelerate clean electrification internationally.
About: We Mean Business Coalition is a global nonprofit coalition working with the world’s most influential businesses to take action on climate change.